Something is drawing Julia Collins to Magical Matchups, Chicago's newest dating service that is run by a crackpot old woman named Verna. Five minutes after they've met, Verna introduces "the man Julia will marry" - her best friend's ex. The old woman had better be a witch, because although Scot's kiss ignites a fire in her soul, there's only one way Julia can see them finding a happily ever after. By magic alone.