Just when Ephram Brown starts to think Everwood isn't so bad after all, everything changes. Thanks to Dr. Brown's skill as a neurosurgeon, Colin Hart comes out of his coma and makes a miraculous recovery. The town's golden boy is back, and everyone is thrilled -- no one more so than Amy.

She has her boyfriend back, and that's the only thing in the world that matters to her. Ephram's friendship and the kiss he and Amy shared just before Colin woke up seem to have slipped her mind completely. The irony is that while she's trying to pretend she barely knows Ephram, Colin wants him to be his new best friend. That's when things get awkward.

Amy and her brother, Bright, want the old Colin back -- the one they used to spend all of their time with before the accident. What they don't realize is, that Colin may be gone forever.