As a teenager, Chauncey Greer found fame as a member of a boy band--and love with band member Sweet D. When their relationship was discovered, it marked the end of Chauncey's aspirations as a singer. Now a forty-year-old gay man, a devout Christian, and the owner of a lucrative greeting-card company, Chauncey rediscovers his joy in singing as a soloist in the church choir. Then he receives an invitation to sing at a revival meeting featuring an appearance by a vocally anti-gay bishop with a secret link to Chauncey's past, forcing Chauncey to choose whether or not to out himself.