Jane Wheel is an avid antique collector. She owns too much stuff and decides to have her viry first garage sale. Jane gets a phone call from her mother, Nellie. She is calling to tell about a mysterious discovery on a neighbor's property. Jane volunteers to go to her hometown, Kankakee, Illinois, to see if she can help the neighbor, Fuzzy Neilson, sort things out. Jane manages to uncover the town's buried secrets. She must sort rumor and gossip from true crime before it's too late.