When circumstances forced Sarah Drummond to leave Butte Creek five years ago, she left behind her family and the man she loved, Josh Hightower. When her mother suffers a stroke, Sarah returns to Butte Creek to face old demons and her former love. Josh, shocked to learn that she is a single mother, is convinced that Sarah's 4-year-old, J. J., is his son. Sarah rejects Josh's claim until she learns that he has not loved another woman since she left. She opens her heart to Josh, finally sharing her confusion and the terrible secret that led her to leave town so many years before. He's Got His Daddy's Eyes is the tender story of two damaged lovers who learn to heal each other.