Entering Amanda's yard in the present day from 1863 on the back of a spirit horse, Trey has a bullet in his back and stolen bank notes in his saddlebags. Amanda finds the dark, handsome Trey fascinating, but his bewilderment of modern life, his fear of the police, and one soul-stirring kiss makes it clear that even though he robbed a bank in the past, she would gift him with her heart.